DOES GOD RECOGNIZE UNLAWFUL MARRIAGES AND UNLAWFUL DIVORCES?
Recently while discussing the subject of marriage and divorce, a preacher took the position that God does not recognize UNLAWFUL divorces or UNLAWFUL marriages. He took that position in an effort to justify a "divorced" (or "put away") person if that person marries another. He contended that God did not RECOGNIZE a divorce or a marriage of which He did not approve.
In the discussion mentioned above, the situation was this. A wife had "divorced" (or "put away") her husband. At the time of the divorce, neither she nor her husband had accused the other of committing fornication. Later (after he was "put away" i.e., "divorced"), he claimed that he learned that his wife was guilty of fornication before she "divorced" (i.e., "put away") him. Later the wife married another. Referring to the "divorced" (i.e. "put away") husband, the preacher said: "______divorced his wife because of adultery and he has the right to marry another." In the discussion that followed the preacher took the position that God did not RECOGNIZE the fact that the wife had "divorced" (i.e., "put away") her husband since she had no Scriptural right to divorce him.
Of course, the wife had no SCRIPTURAL REASON (and thus no Scriptural right) to divorce him in view of the teaching of Jesus in Matt. 19:9. Therfore she sinned in so doing!
Now the question that we are considering is not: Does God approve of a wife divorcing or putting away her husband without a Scriptural cause (his committing fornication and her divorcing him for that reason)? We know that GOD DOES NOT APPROVE OF IT because of the teaching of Matt. 19:3-9; Mk. 10:2-12; Rom. 7:2 ,3; 1 Cor. 7:10-15; Lk. 6:31, etc. The question we are considering is this:
Does God RECOGNIZE an unlawful (or unscriptural or an unapproved of) divorce or marriage? Does God recognize the fact that a marriage or a divorce has occurred?
By "unlawful" I mean not permitted or authorized by God; not according to the law of God. By "recognize" I mean know, acknowledge or admit.
There are marriages that are in accordance with civil law but are CONTRARY to the law of God. There are divorces that are in accordance with civil law but are CONTRARY to the law of God. Does God RECOGNIZE that these marriages and divorces exist? Without doubt, God recognizes that these marriages and divorces exist but He certainly doe not authorize, sanction or approve of them.
Mark 6:17,18 says: "For Herod himself had sent forth and laid hold upon John, and bound him in prison for Herodias' sake, his brother Philip's wife: for he had married her. For John had said unto Herod, It is not lawful for thee to have thy brother's wife." (Also read Mark 6:14-16, 19-29, and Matthew 14:1-12). From these Scriptures please not the follow facts:
1. Herod has John put in prison.
2. Herodias has a quarrel against John because he condemned Herod for having her (Herodias). Herod imprisoned John because of Herodias.
3. Herodias was Philip's wife. Philip was Herod's brother.
4. Herod "HAD MARRIED HER (Herodias)." vs. 17.
NOTE: It is obvious that a MARRIAGE (according to civil law) existed between Herod and Herodias "FOR HE HAD MARRIED HER."
FURTHER NOTE: It is obvious that a DIVORCE (according to civil law) had taken place between Philip and Herodias or at this time Herodias was in a polygamous MARRIAGE with Herod.
QUESTION: Would civil law have allowed Herod to have married Herodias without a divorce from Philip?
5. John had said unto Herod: "It is not lawful for thee to have thy brother's wife" (vs. 18).
NOTE: Since "HE HAD MARRIED HER" he now had her! It is obvious that Herod had Herodias in a marriage relationship. God's Word so teaches!
6. It was "NOT LAWFUL" for Herod to "HAVE" Herodias although "he had married her."
7. John said that Herod was MARRIED to Herodias and the he had her but it was "not lawful." It was not according to the law of God.
NOTE: Without doubt, here is a marriage (of Herod and Herodias) that God recognized but did not approve of!
8. Herodias was still PHILIP'S WIFE although she was now MARRIED to Herod! For further clarification please note the following.
(a) Legally (i.e., according to civil law but not according to the law of God and thus without God's approval) Herodias was now the wife of Herod "for he had married her."
(b) Lawfully (i.e., according to the law of God and thus with God's approval) Herodias was still Philip's wife! Although Herod married Herodias legally (i.e., according to civil law), it was "not lawful" (according to the law of God since God did not approve of it) for Herod to "have her".
Therefore, John reproved Herod for having her! God recognized the marriage between Herod and Herodias but God did not approve of it! It was an unlawful marriage! Herodias was still Philip's wife as far as the law of God was concerned.
In Lk. 16:18 Jesus said: "Whosoever putteth away his wife, and marrieth another, committeth adultery: and whosever marreth her which is put away from her husband committeth adultery."
NOTE: The NKJV and the NASV use the words "divorces" and "is divorced" instead of "putteth away" and "is put away."
FURTHER NOTE: Jesus recognized the fact that a person can divorce (put away) his or her spouse without God's approval. Thus it would be unlawful!
Mark 10:12 says: "...Whosoever shall put away his wife, and marry another, committeth adulter against her. And if a woman shall put away her husband, and be married to another, she committeth adultery."
NOTE: The NKJV and the NASV use the word "divorces" instead of "shall put away."
NOTE: This also shows that a person may divorce a spouse without God's approval! Such a divorce would be unlawful according to the law of God although God recognized it as a divorce.
In Matthew 19:9 we read: ''...Whosoever shall put away his wife except it be for fornication, and shall marry another, committeth adultery; and who marrieth her which is put away doth commit adultery."
NOTE: The NKJV and the NASV use the words "divorces" and "is divorced" instead of "shall put away" and "is put away." We learn from this verse that a divorce for the cause of fornication is lawful (i.e., it is authorized by the law of God and God approves of it and a divorce for any other reason is "not lawful" and God does not approve of it although He recognizes the fact of the divorce.
In Matthew 5:32 Jesus said: "That whosoever shall put away his wife, saving for the cause of fornication, causeth her to commit adultery: and whosoever shall marry her that is divorced committeth adultery."
NOTE: We see from this verse that putting away is the same as divorcing. If a man divorces his wife for any other reason than fornication he causeth her to commit adultery when she has sexual relations with another. It is obvious that God recognizes a divorce for other reasons than fornication but He does not approve of it.
When a divorce is granted because of fornication God both recognizes and approves of it because it is according to civil law and it is in keeping with the law of God.
There are many things that God recognized (or recognizes) but He did not (or does not) approve of them. Here are some of them:
1. Cain killed Abel. (See Gen. 4:1-15; Heb. 11:4; 1 Jno.
2. Lamech "took unto him two wives." (Gen. 4:19; 5:4; Mk. 10:6-9).
3. Homosexuality. (Lev. 18:22; 20:13; Rom. 1:26-32; etc.).
4. The burnt offerings and meat offerings in Amos 5:21-27.
5. Judas betrayed Him! (See Matt. 26:;47-50; Mk. 14:43-46; Lk. 22:48).
6. Peter denied Him! (See Lk. 22:54-62; Mk. 14:66-72).
7. Jezebel committed fornication. (See Rev. 2:20-23).
8. The church at Ephesus had left her first love. (See Rev. 2:1-7).
9. The church at Sardis was dead. (See Rev. 3:1-6).
10. The church of the Laodiceans was luke-warm. (See Rev. 14:14-22).
When a person commits the works of the flesh God recognizes the fact that he does but God does not approve of his actions. Yes, God RECOGNIZES unscriptural marriages and divorces but He certainly DOES NOT APPROVE OF THEM!
By: Carrol R. Sutton, via. The Jackson Drive News and Notes of May 6, 2001. No. 18.
Return to the General Articles page
Return to the Marriage, Divorce, Remarriage special study
Home / Bible studies / Bible Survey / Special Studies / General Articles / Non-Bible Articles / Sermons / Sermon Outlines / Links / Questions and Answers / What Saith The Scriptures /Daily Devotional / Correspondence Courses / What is the Church of Christ / Book: Christian Growth / Website Policy / E-mail / About Me /